Nothing Like A Last-Minute Decision
Matt Bodenschatz | National Hockey League
Aug 28, 09:29 AM | Hype this story!
Just two months ago, the world watched as Scott Niedermayer and Teemu Selanne hoisted the Stanley Cup above their heads.
At the time, many, if not most, hockey fans figured it would be the last time they would see these two great players.
Now, with just weeks remaining until training camps across the NHL are slated to begin, their pending retirements are still….well, pending.
At what point will they make announcements? Better yet, at what point will the Anaheim Ducks management demand decisions?
Apparently, the answer to the second question may come soon.
“Obviously, at some point I have to ask Scotty if he plans to come to camp or not,” said general manager Brian Burke in an interview with the OC Register’s Dan Wood. “I have to ask them both that. I probably will pretty quickly, probably by this weekend. My guess would be that they’re probably not. If that were their intent, I think I would have heard by now.”
That question should have been asked much earlier. Don’t get me wrong, they have earned time to make their decisions, but would giving an answer by mid-July or early-August be too much to ask?
According to TSN.ca, Niedermayer had the following to say:
“I’m in a different spot, no question about it. But again, I’m just trying to make the right decision. I know it’s unfortunate that people are waiting to see what the decision is – it’s not fun, but that’s the way it is right now.”
So he’s trying to suggest that he has not yet made a decision?
If in fact that is the case, his decision is made. He does not want to leave the NHL.
But, like Burke, I tend to believe that both players are just delaying the inevitable: announcing retirement.
Selanne, meanwhile, is keeping quiet.
Nothing like a last minute decision.
I’m a huge fan of both of these players, and was thrilled to see Selanne regain his form of old with the Ducks and to see Niedermayer win the Cup with his brother Rob.
But at what point will this end?
Do these players not realize that, by failing to give a decision, they have tampered with the team’s summer plans?
Sure, defenseman Mathieu Schneider was brought in as an insurance policy in case Niedermayer retires, and forward Todd Bertuzzi was brought in to lessen the effects of losing Selanne.
Neither of the reinforcements, however, lives up to the standards of the potentially-retiring players.
And if Niedermayer (who remains under contract) does retire, the Ducks will have $6.75 million of cap space to work with – or $6.75 million of cap space that could have been used on another legitimate free agent replacement.
There’s also this: If both decide to return, there may not be room under the salary cap.
According to NHL Numbers, the Ducks will have $1.376 million of cap space available if Niedermayer returns.
Since Selanne is an unrestricted free agent, his salary is not included. Will he be willing to play for a measly $1.376 million? It seems unlikely, seeing that he made $3.75 million last year.
Then again, the “Finnish Flash” loves Anaheim and has won the Stanley Cup, which he so desperately wanted. Maybe he would be willing to play for less?
Regardless, the Ducks are in a tight situation that has been presented by the selfishness of two of the NHL’s great players.
The decision to retire surely is a tough one, but the task of running a hockey team also is tough, and Niedermayer and Selanne certainly aren’t making it any easier.
It’s time for these two veterans to make decisions, to let the hockey world know where they stand.
It’s time to move on or move out.

Comments
Ashley
Aug 28, 09:54 AM
Burke must be ticked that he hasn’t heard anything from Neidermayer or Selanne, because if they are returning, he will have some serious juggling to do. Somehow I can’t see Burke signing Selanne for $1.376M because that would put them at the absolute max. I don’t think it’s a good idea to leave yourself with no room under the cap, so that leaves the question: would Selanne play another season for something pretty close to the league minimum? JR said back in April that he’d make that deal, but I don’t know if Selanne would. I guess Burkie could always dump some players for more cap room…man, this could end up being a mess.
Matt Bodenschatz
Aug 28, 10:05 AM
There’s also the option of trading a player to make salary cap room. I’m not that familiar with the Ducks, but I’m sure there is a player on the team that is overpriced for what he does, yet would remain a tradeable commodity. I think the discussion is moot, though, as I truly see both players announcing their retirements in the next couple days.
Michael Farkas
Aug 28, 09:29 PM
What’s Neidermayer’s motivation? 4 Cups, check, Conn Smythe, check, winning Cup with brother, check…
Ashley
Aug 28, 10:06 PM
My guess is that Selanne will retire, and I wouldn’t be surprised if Neidermayer returned for another go at it. Neidermayer’s motivation might be that he just wants to play hockey…then again, who knows. Guess we’ll find out soon enough, eh?
Matt Bodenschatz
Aug 29, 08:25 AM
Motivation? There really is none other than for the love of the sport. The same can be said for Selanne, though he has not has as much success as Niedermayer has. Both players would be leaving on their own terms, while still atop the game.
The point is not that they should return, but rather that they should simply give a decision — or, more accurately, should have given a decision about a month ago at the latest.
DaBich
Aug 29, 09:43 PM
Like you said, time to chit or get off the pot!!!
I’d love to see both of them play again, but they ARE being rather selfish leaving it so long.
Matt Bodenschatz
Aug 29, 10:30 PM
Exactly. In no way was I suggesting that I want to see either player retire. The game of hockey needs both of them. But by playing the waiting game for so long, both players are showing a lack of respect for the Ducks.
Commenting is closed for this article.